Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support Tone Authority.
The ultimate showdown between two legendary dirt pedals.
Big Muff vs RAT: Which Pedal Is Better for Heavy Riffs?
When it comes to massive riffs, sludgy fuzz, gnarly distortion, and doom-soaked sustain, two pedals dominate the conversation:
- The Electro-Harmonix Big Muff Pi (and its many variants)
- The ProCo RAT 2
Both have shaped entire genres — grunge, stoner rock, doom metal, punk, garage rock, alt-rock, and modern heavy music.
But which one is right for your rig?
Let’s break it down.
Quick Verdict: Muff = Fuzz Wall. RAT = Aggressive Distortion.
If you want huge, syrupy, sustaining fuzz → pick the Big Muff.
If you want tight, punchy, cutting distortion → pick the RAT.
If you want doom, sludge, shoegaze → Big Muff.
If you want metal, punk, hardcore, classic distortion → RAT.
That’s the short answer.
Now here’s the deep dive.
What the Big Muff Sounds Like
The Big Muff is all about thickness, sustain, and a massive low-end wall.
Tone Characteristics
- Huge, smooth fuzz
- Long sustain
- Thick low-mid body
- Scooped mids
- Perfect for giant riffs or singing leads
- Can feel loose or boomy if paired with lots of bass
Best For
- Doom metal
- Stoner rock
- Sludge
- Shoegaze
- Grunge
- Huge leads (Gilmour-style)
Why Guitarists Love It
The Muff turns your guitar into a tsunami of fuzz.
It’s not subtle — it’s overwhelming in the best way.
👉 Check Price: Electro-Harmonix Big Muff Pi on Amazon
👉 Check Price: EHX Big Muff on zZounds
What the RAT Sounds Like
The ProCo RAT is not a fuzz.
It’s a distortion with fuzz-like edges, a unique voice, and a famously usable filter knob.
Tone Characteristics
- Tight low-end
- Aggressive midrange
- Cuts through mixes
- More controlled than the Muff
- Can do distortion → fuzz → almost overdrive
- Works in standard or drop tunings
Best For
- Metal (classic, thrash, hardcore, metalcore)
- Punk
- Hard rock
- Alternative
- Noise rock
- Modern chugging riffs
Why Guitarists Love It
The RAT is punchy, mean, tight, and versatile.
It doesn’t get lost in a mix — it slices through.
👉 Check Price: ProCo RAT 2 on Amazon
👉 Check Price: RAT 2 on zZounds
Big Muff vs RAT: Tone Comparison
| Feature | Big Muff | RAT |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Fuzz | Distortion |
| Gain Character | Smooth, saturated | Aggressive, gritty |
| Sustain | Infinite | Moderate |
| Low End | Massive | Tight |
| High End | Smooth | Cutting |
| Mids | Scooped | Forward |
| Best For | Doom, grunge, shoegaze | Metal, punk, thrash |
| Mix Presence | Can get buried | Cuts through easily |
| Control | Looser | More precise |
Which Pedal Is Better for Heavy Riffs?
Choose the Big Muff if:
- You love Sleep, Boris, Electric Wizard, Smashing Pumpkins, Dinosaur Jr.
- You want a massive, doomy, sustaining fuzz wall
- You don’t mind mids being scooped
- You play through a loud amp that can compensate for low-end bloom
Choose the RAT if:
- You love Metallica (early), GnR, Foo Fighters, Mastodon, Every Time I Die, Nirvana
- You want tight distortion that responds well to palm muting
- You need mids to cut through a mix
- You want one pedal that covers a huge range of heavy tones
Which One Is More Versatile?
The RAT. No contest.
It can do edge-of-breakup → distortion → fuzzy chaos depending on the gain/filter settings.
The Big Muff is more one-trick — but it’s a very good trick.
Final Recommendation
If you want heavy, tight, aggressive riffs → RAT.
If you want massive, thick, doomy fuzz walls → Big Muff.
Both are legendary.
Both are affordable.
Both are essential weapons in a guitarist’s arsenal.
FAQ: Big Muff vs RAT
Is the RAT good for metal?
Yes — especially classic thrash, punk-influenced metal, metalcore, and hardcore. It stays tight under high gain.
Is the Big Muff good for metal?
It works best for doom, stoner, sludge, and drone metal — not fast palm-muted riffs.
Which pedal cuts through the mix better?
The RAT. Its midrange is perfect for band settings.
Does the Big Muff get muddy?
It can, especially on bass-heavy rigs. Using an EQ pedal or an amp with strong mids helps.
Can I stack these two pedals?
Yes! Many players run RAT → Big Muff for wild, sustaining textures.
Which is better for beginners?
The RAT — it’s more flexible and easier to dial in.
You Might Also Like:
- Best Guitar Cleaning Kits & Fretboard Conditioners (2025 Guide)
- Best Guitar Picks for Beginners, Shredders & Strummers (2025 Guide)
- Best Electric Guitar Strings for Beginners & Pros (2025 Buyer’s Guide)
- Best Guitar Straps for Comfort, Style & Security (2025 Guide)
- Best Budget Guitar Loop Pedals Under $100 (2025 Guide)
- Best Affordable Overdrive Pedals for Guitarists (2025 Guide)
- JamPlay for Intermediate Guitarists: Break Through the Plateau (2025 Guide)
- Best Pedals for Guitar Solos (2025 Guide)
Leave a Reply